Well after a lot of thought and going back and forth on this, I decided to do away with the probabtion/redemption section. It was far to complex and problematic to begin with.
If casinos screw up - they screw up - and if it's serious enough to cause grief to players, they are rogued or "not recommended" and there they dwell.
But I have to keep things updated. If casinos are making serious changes in fixing whatever was screwed up, then in my opinion their screwups can become "Past Issues".
https://www.casinomeister.com/rogue-casinos/
In my opinion, this is much better than some arbitrary "probation" period, or better than me waving my magic voodoo stick over some casino operation declaring them redeemed. That's ridiculous.
Past issues are just that - past issues. There is no time limit. And the casino operators know that everyone (who cares) is watching them. Their feet will always be held to the fire because they know they need to continue doing what is expected of them.
I think this will work much better for everyone. And players are given more responsiblity to be able to make intelligent choices on their own - this is an important thing.
I want to thank all of you for your suggestions and feedback. I've used a number of your comments here:
https://www.casinomeister.com/rogue-casinos/