I have no experience with Redbet, but I do not agree that Casino Rewards is a "clip joint" as I DO have experience there of being a VIP, and I also know that Kahnawake have changed for the better, so Casino Rewards would suffer for making a bad decision.
Redbet in this matter have committed the SAME misjudgement as Casino Rewards had a while ago, for which they had a slapped wrist from Kahnawake. They too had a one welcome bonus per player policy, and used a discretionary rather than absolute attitude to enforcement, just as Redbet have. Also like Redbet, Casino Rewards did not have this particular restriction listed with the rest of the bonus terms, but as a clause in the general terms. Kahnawake ruled that this was not sufficiently clear, and so they shared the blame for a player who didn't read both sets of terms. This lead to Kahnawake ordering CR to pay half the disputed winnings they had confiscated.
We cannot have one rule for Redbet, and another for those perceived to be lesser operations. Rather, it is Redbet that have dropped the ball in allowing this lack of clarity to exist in an otherwise "stellar" operation.
I had a go at Cassava for the very same thing, a lack of clarity over their one welcome bonus across all Cassava white labels policy that was catching players out because CS were giving out the wrong information, and the term governing this was situated away from the rest of the bonus terms. Redbet don't get a free ride because of who they are, it is what they do that counts.
Granted, they tend to honour such mistakes, not something that one can say of Cassava.
When the earlier case arose, the term seemed to be absolute, not discretionary, and was the grounds used for the action taken.
Just because a player took all three bonuses doesn't mean they are a scammer. It is how they play those boni that counts - meet the playthrough, and the terms of play such as no whole of bankroll bets, and they should be seen for what they are, someone who wants to win, just like the casino.
Casinos don't operate to entertain themselves, they operate to outsmart players through slick marketing, making players feel they have a better chance of winning than they actually do. Sometimes, a player is too smart to fall for the marketing, but sees and seizes any opportunities within that could shift the odds in their favour, and this is almost always to be found in the bonus offers.
Later on, I am off to Tesco for a spot of "advantage shopping"
