Brexit - whats the difference.....

Just putting some perspective on it, that's all.

You see, I closely follow the politics in my home country and as I have alluded to a number of times, you may as well watch the UK politics, just in a different language. Same problems such as the influx of immigrants, the standard of living crisis, the handling of Covid. You name it, what we had/have here in the UK is being repeated in Holland and without a doubt in Germany et al.

Blaming Brexit for it, rather gleefully as you do if I may add, is not the answer to the crisis. There are many worldwide factors involved that have absolutely sod all to do with Brexit that is putting pressure on people around the world.

I assure you there's nothing remotely gleeful about it, the UK choosing to blow its own feet off has been a source of dismay to me ever since the referendum result was announced. That 'Project Fear' has turned into 'Project Reality' is a simple statement of fact.

There's no pleasure in 'I told you so' when the subject of that statement is the weakening on the world stage of an entire nation, which is what the UK has done. That's not even the fault of those who voted to leave, it was May and Johnson who decided to take the UK down the calamitous 'Hard Brexit' route, where more capable politicians could have delivered on the result of the referendum without slipping a noose around the country's neck.

What does slightly irk me is people arguing, in spite of all the evidence to the contrary, that black is white, up is down, 2+2=5 and It's Nothing To Do With Brexit Mate, which I honestly think should be the epitaph for some folks.
 
I assure you there's nothing remotely gleeful about it, the UK choosing to blow its own feet off has been a source of dismay to me ever since the referendum result was announced. That 'Project Fear' has turned into 'Project Reality' is a simple statement of fact.

There's no pleasure in 'I told you so' when the subject of that statement is the weakening on the world stage of an entire nation, which is what the UK has done. That's not even the fault of those who voted to leave, it was May and Johnson who decided to take the UK down the calamitous 'Hard Brexit' route, where more capable politicians could have delivered on the result of the referendum without slipping a noose around the country's neck.

What does slightly irk me is people arguing, in spite of all the evidence to the contrary, that black is white, up is down, 2+2=5 and It's Nothing To Do With Brexit Mate, which I honestly think should be the epitaph for some folks.

I disagree. You continue to say that the state of this country is to do with Brexit.

Don't then have a go at people to look at the state of Europe because if we stayed in Europe then, by your reasoning, we would have been much better off.

Take foodbanks as an example. Usuage here in the UK has gone up, but it also has in Holland:
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.


There are many more comparisons that I can make. Things that have gone "tits up" here in Blighty have equally gone tits up in Europe.

By your reasoning if we had stayed in Europe we would be on the same standard as them, but that then includes increased proverty, increased fuel prices, increased cost of living etc.
 
I disagree. You continue to say that the state of this country is to do with Brexit.

Don't then have a go at people to look at the state of Europe because if we stayed in Europe then, by your reasoning, we would have been much better off.

Take foodbanks as an example. Usuage here in the UK has gone up, but it also has in Holland:
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.


There are many more comparisons that I can make. Things that have gone "tits up" here in Blighty have equally gone tits up in Europe.

By your reasoning if we had stayed in Europe we would be on the same standard as them, but that then includes increased proverty, increased fuel prices, increased cost of living etc.

With respect interlog, I don't say 'the state of this country is to do with Brexit', I never have, and I never will, because blaming everything that ails the UK on a single factor (be it Brexit or Covid or war in Ukraine or whatever) is clearly stupid.

What I do say is that Brexit is making things worse, it's an extra drag on the UK and its economy, at a time when we really could do without it. Rejoining the Single Market and Customs Union would fix an awful lot of that, but the UK could remain outside the EU. (Admittedly that involves some compromises that very Brexity types won't like, and Farage will pop a theatrical gasket (whilst secretly being delighted that something is happening that makes him vaguely relevant again, so he can stop hawking his horrible gin), but there's an increasing acceptance in many circles now that the UK is seriously suffering outside the Single Market, it's not something that will correct itself, it's not something that will ease over time, it's a never-ending fire that we can't put out.)

There's a decent thread here, will only take anyone a couple of minutes to read it.

1663515297354.png

 
With respect interlog, I don't say 'the state of this country is to do with Brexit', I never have, and I never will, because blaming everything that ails the UK on a single factor (be it Brexit or Covid or war in Ukraine or whatever) is clearly stupid.

What I do say is that Brexit is making things worse, it's an extra drag on the UK and its economy, at a time when we really could do without it. Rejoining the Single Market and Customs Union would fix an awful lot of that, but the UK could remain outside the EU. (Admittedly that involves some compromises that very Brexity types won't like, and Farage will pop a theatrical gasket (whilst secretly being delighted that something is happening that makes him vaguely relevant again, so he can stop hawking his horrible gin), but there's an increasing acceptance in many circles now that the UK is seriously suffering outside the Single Market, it's not something that will correct itself, it's not something that will ease over time, it's a never-ending fire that we can't put out.)

There's a decent thread here, will only take anyone a couple of minutes to read it.

View attachment 172587



But you do it every single time. Some bad news story in the UK, bang it goes in the Brexit thread. It almost feels like you get some kick out of it.

But when others then respond and say, but the same is happening in Europe (such as the Euro down on the Dollar just as the £ is down on the dollar, a trade deficit just like the UK etc.) you then attempt to defend it off with "look at that bee" or something like that.

It is you pinning every bad news story on Brexit, still a gleefully and "told you so" attitude in my opinion.
 
But you do it every single time. Some bad news story in the UK, bang it goes in the Brexit thread. It almost feels like you get some kick out of it.

But when others then respond and say, but the same is happening in Europe (such as the Euro down on the Dollar just as the £ is down on the dollar, a trade deficit just like the UK etc.) you then attempt to defend it off with "look at that bee" or something like that.

It is you pinning every bad news story on Brexit, still a gleefully and "told you so" attitude in my opinion.

But once again interlog I'd have to disagree, the three politics threads I'm active in are the General Election thread, the Leadership Contest thread and the Brexit thread. (I had to duck out of the Covid thread for my own sanity, IIRC I last posted in there over 18 months ago.)

I'll post in whichever one seems most appropriate, if I think the prime factor involved is Brexit, I'll stick it in here - and I'll go days or weeks without posting in this thread, it's not like I even remotely post every 'Bad News Brexit Story' that crosses my desk as it were, otherwise it really would be a daily cavalcade of awful news. (Feel free to check out the other two politics threads I regularly post to, loads of stuff in both of them that haven't come anywhere near the Brexit thread.)

My post this morning literally opened with this:

1663520397894.png

Now you might disagree with my thought process or conclusion (which is fine), but the idea it's just BAD NEWS STORY MUST POST IN BREXIT THREAD IMMEDIATELY doesn't hold up to scrutiny.

The fact that some other European countries are suffering some of the same problems as the UK to a greater or lesser degree (but let's be honest, almost always lesser) really isn't the point, the point is that Brexit is making things worse for the UK, and there's an increasing amount of data to back that assertion up.

I've said this before and I'll say it again, I would be absolutely delighted to be proved wrong on this, and that Brexit is in fact giving the UK some unique advantage on the world stage to combat the headwinds it's facing, the problem is there's precisely zero evidence of it. (Unless you're a millionaire banker in London who's just had the cap on his bonuses removed.)
 
The fact that some other European countries are suffering some of the same problems as the UK to a greater or lesser degree (but let's be honest, almost always lesser) really isn't the point, the point is that Brexit is making things worse for the UK, and there's an increasing amount of data to back that assertion up.

But that is just the issue. It was YOU that posted in here about the £ being low against the $ and blame Brexit for it. Is that same Brexit to blame for the Euro doing the exact same things against the $.

It was YOU posting that picture of the boat of immigrants blaming Brexit for it, when in Holland immigration is up and only last week in Sweden a far right anti immigration party is the second largest party of Sweden. Europe is struggling with immigration as much as the UK is, so is Brexit to blame for that too?

Maybe you should actually watch and read some of the European channels and newspapers and perhaps then you will find carbon copy problems of the UK that can't be blamed on Brexit like you blame as much as you can on it.

As for the bankers, as I said good luck to them. Now tell me, how has the fact that they are going to get some fat bonuses going to detrimentally effect you or how is it going to detrimentally effect the country?
 
But once again interlog I'd have to disagree, the three politics threads I'm active in are the General Election thread, the Leadership Contest thread and the Brexit thread. (I had to duck out of the Covid thread for my own sanity, IIRC I last posted in there over 18 months ago.)
And there was me thinking it was because you copped a lot of heat for being an arrogant cockwomble, who took GREAT DELIGHT in saying that you could go for a meal and a pint in your local, while anyone who was not located in the Isle Of MOAN could not.

And why did you do that?
Oh yeah, that's right. You "got frustrated" at the fact that several members of this forum were not prepared to see things from your point of view.
So you resorted to flat out needling people instead for shits and giggles.
And you didn't make any effort whatsoever to hide your glee, did you? No Sir!
When you copped the deserved backlash, you offered up a laughably weak and insincere apology before promptly disappearing for a month.

Still, at least you had the good grace to admit to "ducking out" of the thread. By your standards, that's a stunningly self-critical act :rolleyes:
 
And there was me thinking it was because you copped a lot of heat for being an arrogant cockwomble, who took GREAT DELIGHT in saying that you could go for a meal and a pint in your local, while anyone who was not located in the Isle Of MOAN could not.

And why did you do that?
Oh yeah, that's right. You "got frustrated" at the fact that several members of this forum were not prepared to see things from your point of view.
So you resorted to flat out needling people instead for shits and giggles.
And you didn't make any effort whatsoever to hide your glee, did you? No Sir!
When you copped the deserved backlash, you offered up a laughably weak and insincere apology before promptly disappearing for a month.

Still, at least you had the good grace to admit to "ducking out" of the thread. By your standards, that's a stunningly self-critical act :rolleyes:

Well the good thing here is that the history is still there to see.

So here's the post in question - Corona virus - Covid 19 discussion - Page 443 - Casinomeister Forum

You can read before or after that as you see fit to get some of the context around it.

And here's my 'laughably weak and insincere apology' that I posted the next day - Corona virus - Covid 19 discussion - Page 444 - Casinomeister Forum

Yeah, I fucked up and made a mistake, I owned up to the mistake and I apologised for it, you can read it as 'laughably insincere' if you want, but that is most certainly not the spirit in which it was made.

For further context, here's a post where I was explicitly critical of the approach taken on the IOM, and only made at all because I was accused of 'running away' from the thread - Corona virus - Covid 19 discussion - Page 454 - Casinomeister Forum

And yes this was after I took a break from the thread, but it had nothing to do with 'the backlash', the records will show I continued to post regularly to the thread after 'the backlash', I just honestly gave up in the face of too much anti-science/anti-fact nonsense, a move which many other CM members made in the end too, which is why the thread is now a wasteland.

People can read those and draw whatever conclusions they wish.
 
Last edited:
But that is just the issue. It was YOU that posted in here about the £ being low against the $ and blame Brexit for it. Is that same Brexit to blame for the Euro doing the exact same things against the $.

It was YOU posting that picture of the boat of immigrants blaming Brexit for it, when in Holland immigration is up and only last week in Sweden a far right anti immigration party is the second largest party of Sweden. Europe is struggling with immigration as much as the UK is, so is Brexit to blame for that too?

Maybe you should actually watch and read some of the European channels and newspapers and perhaps then you will find carbon copy problems of the UK that can't be blamed on Brexit like you blame as much as you can on it.

As for the bankers, as I said good luck to them. Now tell me, how has the fact that they are going to get some fat bonuses going to detrimentally effect you or how is it going to detrimentally effect the country?

The key point here interlog, surely, is that the sales pitch for Brexit was that it was going to make things better, it was going to improve things, it was going to open up new opportunities for the UK once it was freed from the shackles of the EU, and allow the UK to do things that no other country was capable of, because we were moving in a bold new direction.

If we're just at 'well at least we're only as shit as everywhere else' then it's failed on its own terms. Brexit was explicitly pitched as being able to 'fix immigration', we all remember this right?

1663528285415.png

There is a general consensus (with data!) now that Brexit has been economically damaging for the UK, depending on the business sector in question the impact could have been anywhere from 'not that bad really' to 'utterly and completely devastating'. I can at least understand, on some basic level, the argument 'Well it was worth it to sort out the immigration problem', but it hasn't even done that.

I didn't blame Brexit for the immigrants in the dinghies, I pointed out that Brexit promised to 'fix it', but it didn't even do that.

So if we're taking the pain from Brexit (and there is certainly pain), then we should be able to point to the rewards as well, the trade-offs that were made, the losses and the wins - but there are no wins, unless dunover's slightly bizarre rant last Christmas about being able to do his farts in freedom counts.

Brexit was never going to survive contact with reality, and so it has proved to be the case.
 
We're going to have to rejoin the Single Market and Customs Union eventually, the only variables are how long it'll take and how much damage the UK's economy will sustain in the interim.

1663664903451.png
 
And this is a surprise??? It was only if Trump was President that a US / UK trade deal would go ahead. The EU do not have a trade deal with the US.

Biden's position on Northern Ireland is diametrically the opposite to the UK in the current wrangling over the EU trying to force the UK from cutting off Northern Ireland.

This is a non story Chopley, which the likes of JoB et al are trying to gain mileage from. Nothing to see here, move along.
 
And this is a surprise??? It was only if Trump was President that a US / UK trade deal would go ahead. The EU do not have a trade deal with the US.

Biden's position on Northern Ireland is diametrically the opposite to the UK in the current wrangling over the EU trying to force the UK from cutting off Northern Ireland.

This is a non story Chopley, which the likes of JoB et al are trying to gain mileage from. Nothing to see here, move along.

Really? Because I remember a trade deal with the US being promised as a major Brexit benefit, and also being heralded as a prime example of what the UK could do on the world stage once it'd left the EU.

Trade deals take years to negotiate, so the idea it could only happen if Trump was president was a pretty risky bet, plus it wouldn't be Trump doing the negotiations, it'd be a US negotiation team.

It doesn't matter what the administration is in the US, they're not going to let the UK throw NI under the bus, and they're certainly not going to accept the UK ripping up the Northern Ireland Protocol.

The EU doesn't need a trade deal with the US like the UK does, the EU is already one of the largest trading blocs in the world, so it can do a lot of trade with itself. The UK decided to leave that trading bloc and impose economic sanctions on itself, a trade deal with the US was promised as being one of the big Brexit wins that the UK could land for itself.
 
Well it is no surprise here. As soon as Biden was elected the chances of a trade deal were non existent. To state otherwise is disingenious.

Besides I am still waiting for godzilla to arrive which project fear promised us.

Everything we are experiencing now is due to the aftermath of the pandemic and Putin’s illegal invasion in Europe.

Yes the pound has fallen against the dollar, but then the Euro is performing worse.

Yes inflation at 9.9% is high, but yet is lower than some EU states levels ie Spain.

Yes we have stacking on the way to Dover, but the French have been performing go slows year after year at Calais and Dunkirk. Don’t believe me just use google.

You can go on and on about what have we done and we need to rejoin. But that isn’t going to even be an option for 25 years or so - when another referendum should be held. That is, if the EU is still around.

So how about instead of bashing the UK, why not put your energies into trying to work with the hand we all have been dealt??
 
So how about instead of bashing the UK, why not put your energies into trying to work with the hand we all have been dealt??

I made a post doing precisely that back in June or July from memory, I'll see if I can find it.

The problem is that until we're honest about the problem, we can't achieve a solution.

It's like, if we're all stood in a boat with a hole in it, and having to constantly bail out water to stop it from sinking, having a discussion about what colour we should paint the mast isn't going to help much. The sensible thing to say there would be, 'Deciding what colour to paint the mast is certainly a legitimate conversation to have at some point, but we should probably fix that hole first'.

I mean, even dunover, during an admittedly rare moment of clarity, was advocating for a more sensible trading arrangement with the EU not that long ago.

It's clear there are no big new trade deals now, or ever, that are going to even remotely repair the damage that leaving the Single Market and Customs Union has caused. So therefore we either have to accept essentially permanent decline and economic weakness for the UK, or, y'know, fix the hole in the boat.

1663676465583.png
 
Don't worry folks, this one is definitely going to work!

So basically, Brexit has been a sack of shit all along, everything since 2016 has been a disaster, and after twelve years of Tory rule we have a 'putrefying' economy - but Truss is going to fix it all and this Brexit will be great!

I for one, am entirely confident that this 37th reboot of Brexit will be a towering success.

1663837974506.png
1663838046407.png
 
As for the bankers, as I said good luck to them. Now tell me, how has the fact that they are going to get some fat bonuses going to detrimentally effect you or how is it going to detrimentally effect the country?

I meant to reply to this at the time and it dropped out of my mind, so I'll pick it up now if I may, because this is a really important thing to understand, I didn't understand it until relatively recently but once it'd been explained to me by smarter folks than me, and I got my head around it, I understood the significance of it.

Basically it comes down to this, money in and of itself is useless. You can't eat money, you can't live in money, you can't heat your house with money, you can't fill your car up with money - money is simply a token that allows us to purchase actual useful resources.

With money we can buy food, we can eat food.
With money we can rent or buy properties, we can live in properties.
With money we can pay our utility bills, we can heat our homes with electricity, gas, or oil.
With money we can buy petrol/diesel, and fill up our cars to get to work and do the other things we need to do.

You get the idea, money is simply a 'transitory asset' that gives us access to actual meaningful resources. Without that, it's just pieces of paper, there's a reason that a trope of zombie films is hundred dollar bills floating around that everyone ignores, because when money ceases to be able to secure resources, it ceases to have any meaning.

So here's why it matters when the bankers get massive bonuses whilst everyone else in the country gets bugger all.

When the amount of money swirling around increases, the amount of resources doesn't increase along with it. There's no direct correlation between the money supply and, for example, the number of houses that exist.

So we can work out the next bit, what happens when the vast majority of people are getting below inflation pay rises, whilst a few folks up at the top are seeing unfettered growth in their incomes? It's simple, the value of a pound in the pocket becomes less, you need more money to buy the same things you were buying before, from everyday essentials all the way up to hugely expensive purchases such as a house.

So when the Tories gave out a massive tax bonanza to the rich the other week, and uncapped bankers' bonuses, whilst giving a paltry tax cut to everyone else, what's the net effect? Most people get a few quid extra, whilst the already wealthy get loads more, the key point being that 'most people' need to understand that the £100 or whatever they just 'saved', is dwarfed by the tens or hundreds of thousands of pounds that the already wealthy were just gifted, so those people, relatively speaking, just became massively better off and made everyone else poorer - because they have far more of the 'tokens' (money) to compete for scarce resources.

This is why it matters when the rich get richer, because on a fundamental level, we're all still competing for the same resources, money is just a way to secure those resources, which is why home ownership for almost anyone in their twenties now seems like an impossible dream, unless of course their family already has money, in which case the inequality becomes even more entrenched.
 
35 minutes so a bit of an ask, and yes it's GARY again, but this is a guy who worked this shit out in his twenties and is retired in his thirties as a millionaire.

This is a direct timestamped link to a millionaire dreading what's coming down the tracks:

 
I meant to reply to this at the time and it dropped out of my mind, so I'll pick it up now if I may, because this is a really important thing to understand, I didn't understand it until relatively recently but once it'd been explained to me by smarter folks than me, and I got my head around it, I understood the significance of it.

Basically it comes down to this, money in and of itself is useless. You can't eat money, you can't live in money, you can't heat your house with money, you can't fill your car up with money - money is simply a token that allows us to purchase actual useful resources.

With money we can buy food, we can eat food.
With money we can rent or buy properties, we can live in properties.
With money we can pay our utility bills, we can heat our homes with electricity, gas, or oil.
With money we can buy petrol/diesel, and fill up our cars to get to work and do the other things we need to do.

You get the idea, money is simply a 'transitory asset' that gives us access to actual meaningful resources. Without that, it's just pieces of paper, there's a reason that a trope of zombie films is hundred dollar bills floating around that everyone ignores, because when money ceases to be able to secure resources, it ceases to have any meaning.

So here's why it matters when the bankers get massive bonuses whilst everyone else in the country gets bugger all.

When the amount of money swirling around increases, the amount of resources doesn't increase along with it. There's no direct correlation between the money supply and, for example, the number of houses that exist.

So we can work out the next bit, what happens when the vast majority of people are getting below inflation pay rises, whilst a few folks up at the top are seeing unfettered growth in their incomes? It's simple, the value of a pound in the pocket becomes less, you need more money to buy the same things you were buying before, from everyday essentials all the way up to hugely expensive purchases such as a house.

So when the Tories gave out a massive tax bonanza to the rich the other week, and uncapped bankers' bonuses, whilst giving a paltry tax cut to everyone else, what's the net effect? Most people get a few quid extra, whilst the already wealthy get loads more, the key point being that 'most people' need to understand that the £100 or whatever they just 'saved', is dwarfed by the tens or hundreds of thousands of pounds that the already wealthy were just gifted, so those people, relatively speaking, just became massively better off and made everyone else poorer - because they have far more of the 'tokens' (money) to compete for scarce resources.

This is why it matters when the rich get richer, because on a fundamental level, we're all still competing for the same resources, money is just a way to secure those resources, which is why home ownership for almost anyone in their twenties now seems like an impossible dream, unless of course their family already has money, in which case the inequality becomes even more entrenched.
With only paying 10% taxes i'm sure you've had enough money to at least give it a go, no?

Screenshot 2022-10-02 at 21.13.48.png
 
give it a rest chops , I’m not sure if you have noticed that interest rates have rises in parity with the EU ….

Oh yeah , European countries are giving their people 500 euros to offset extra energy bills ..
but you would never have guessed that the UK are doing exactly the same .

Ok what next …

Oh but the pound has gone to shit .. have you seen the war that is going on ? For the last year the USD has been getting stronger , which means that all the other currencies ( including GBP) and your beloved Euro had been getting weaker ..


Ahhh yes , let’s have a look at the current EURUSD price , 0.97999.

Ok so let’s have a look at when that was las the case with the dollar. Hmmm. ….. that would be in December 2002 .


So that was 20 years ago , but for some reason you just want to focus on the UK scenario.


Open your eyes .


The UK still talks to the EU constantly, hence why we have the same energy credit, same covid response on the same day the EU announced restrictions.

The UK still sings from the same hymn sheet even if you don’t realise it .

Did you think post Brexit that the UK would just stop supporting everyone else ??
 
Last edited:
Chopley , Please give your opinion as to why the Euro is the weakest it has been against the USD for 20 years .
 

Attachments

  • D5F47942-DA2C-4BAE-A20F-B01956724342.png
    D5F47942-DA2C-4BAE-A20F-B01956724342.png
    217.5 KB · Views: 6
Last edited:
Chopley , Please give your opinion as to why the Euro is the weakest it has been against the USD for 20 years .

With respect, I don't really care, I explained over in the Leadership thread as to why/how I'm so specifically interested in UK politics, moreover, how the Euro is or isn't performing against the dollar makes no difference to the average UK citizen who's struggling with their bills or staring down the barrel of a ruinous increase in their mortgage payments.

I'll make sure to cast an angry vote in the next French election against Macron, or something.

The dollar is very strong at the moment, everyone knows that.

1664780570503.png
 
With only paying 10% taxes i'm sure you've had enough money to at least give it a go, no?

View attachment 173484

What would you have me do, send extra cash to the IOM government every month on a voluntary basis?

I pay the taxes required of me as per the laws of the land. When I lived in the UK I did the same.
 
I've double-checked that this is a genuine article on the right-wing, Brexity Telegraph's site and it is, it's not some sort of fake.

This is the kind of honesty that's required now, we need to be charting a course back into the Single Market and Customs Union, with the compromises that requires.

We can stay out of the EU, fine, let's not have that fight - but we need back into the Single Market and Customs Union.

You can read the whole article with SINISTER PAYWALL REMOVER TECHNOLOGY here -
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.


1665852405172.png

1665852378893.png
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Meister Ratings

Back
Top