You've all got some good points.
A summary so far:
Pros:
1. The affiliate could offer a better bonus than the default in some cases.
2. Some affiliate-sites can help you solve any problem or dispute with the casino-site. However, several affiliate-sites seems to have that service for all players but they might try a little harder if they know it's one of their affiliated player? Is it possible for the affiliate-site to see the names/ids of all the customer they referred?
3. You support honest and hard-working affiliate-people so they can continue to save the world. Advanced, correct and updated information about casino-sites and games are good but in this context it doesn't really give the player any direct short-term extra to use the affiliate-links.
Cons:
1. There is a risk that the casino-site will offer fewer reload-bonuses if they have to pay affiliate-revenue for the customer as well. This probability is reduced by the fact that the bonus-cost is usually deducted from the gross revenue when the affiliate net revenue is calculated.
2. There is a risk that the casino-site will offer fewer reload-bonuses and/or confiscate funds if the referred affiliate-site has a lot of useful and advanced bonus-strategy information.
Casino rake/cash-back seems to be forbidden in most affiliate-programs. However, the affiliate-sites should be able to offer some sort of sign up reward or benefit without breaking the T&Cs. If this or any other site has something similar you can contact me.
Pros:
1. Yes, this is an advantage.
2. No reputable casinos tell affiliates ANY personal details about the players (i.e. Full names, e-mail or physical address). With a few you can see the player's account ref number - but with no other details this is pretty meaningless.
3. It depends on the affiliate site. The only reason I started my site was because as a player, I got fed up with looking for new casinos but not finding the vital information I needed on existing affy sites. Yeah these other site said "get a YYY% bonus up to $XXX", but what they didn't say was, what is the WR? Is it Cashable or Phantom? Which games are allowed or not? Many don't even say what the software is!
So my site may not add any $value, but it does save player hours of tedious T&Cs reading on multiple casino websites trying to find a bonus which appeals to them, with the games they want to play.
The other factor is, you wont find any rogue casinos on my site - if you just relied on Google for your searching you'd likely end up at one of two rip-off clip-joints. I put in a hell of a lot of hours to get the information for my site, so that players don't have to. I'm sure all the other affiliates who are members here at CM are just the same.
Cons:
1. As per my first reply in this thread - it's make NO difference to the player, unless the casino does not use affiliates at all - and I don't think there are many of them. Affiliate fees are just part of the overheads - just the same as TV ads are for those casinos who use them.
2. No reputable casino would allow themselves to be advertised on an "advantage play" site and then confiscate winnings because of some "spirit of the bonus" rule. Of course, the dodgy and rogue ones would - which is why players have to be careful about where they look and which casinos they chose to play. In essence this is the whole reason CasinoMeister started his site in the first place - to guide players in the direction of the reputable, honest operators and away from the shady casinos on the dark side. Those principles are what make this the best gambling forum on the net.
KK