Logo
external image

Big Pirate Casino

The start of the second week of the month sees the inclusion and review of Big Pirate Casino to Casinomeister. Big Pirate Casino is a Sweepstakes Casino and features a library of over 2,600 games!
Hi Webzcas, would be really interested to understand how in-depth the review process goes for these (and other) casinos - when you (or whoever) tests them, do they go through full verification/test the withdrawal process etc?

I only ask because when you google this particular casino, the trustpilot/reddit reviews are not great but we have seen a couple of sweepstakes casinos added here.

No intention of playing, more just curious about the process
 
Hi,

None of the forum team, myself included write any of the reviews that are published on the site. When Bryan owned CM I did however used to write the news articles and compiled and put together many of the interviews with Game Studios.

Max's Desk piece on the Casino Reviews, is indeed written by Max and I tend to quote pertinent bits from there when I announce a new casino review on the forum.

However, Sweepstakes Casinos this is an area that I have little to no knowledge of. Also there is no Max's Desk area on these reviews.

So when I announce these new reviews that have been published on the site, I only have the review contents to go on.
 
Paid reviews this is the way CM works now i think
While it’s true that casinos do pay to have a review done they don’t have any choice about what we say in the review, see the Max’s Desk sections for instance. The bottom line is that sites like ours need income to survive, and most already do this while we’ve only recently started ; the real question is what you’re willing to do for the money you take. To date we’re trying to draw a line between having an honest review done and having a complimentary review done just because there is money on the table.

That said, we’re still trying to find the right balance. One of the keys to that — in our opinion — is rebooting the User Input on Reviews that Casinomeister used to have via the Meister Minions. I don’t think the Minions program will be reactivated any time soon BUT some mechanism for the Casinomeister readership to provide feedback on Reviews and Ratings is one of the Forum crew’s highest priorities. With that system in place — when it is in place — comments and concerns on a given Review or Rating should be relatively easy to provide: input from readers like yourself will allow us to balance what a Review says with what you’ve actually experienced at the casino.

- Max
 
Last edited:
Hi everyone, since @andysbetting1187 asked earlier about how verification and withdrawals work here—and @maxd mentioned wanting real player experiences to balance out these reviews—I wanted to share what happened to me with Big Pirate (and their sister site, Dorados).

On October 23, 2026, I tried to redeem a $50,000 SC balance on Big Pirate. Even though my account was already verified, they stalled my redemption by forcing me through a repeat verification process. I submitted my driver's license and an official document from my online IRS account as proof-of-address on October 24, and support explicitly confirmed no further documents were needed. Four days later, they rejected those exact documents anyway. Both while the verification was pending and minutes after rejecting it, they sent me free Sweeps Coins telling me to "enjoy the extra playtime." They suddenly approved the exact same documents on October 30, which was conveniently right after my balance had already been played through.

What makes this even worse is that the entire time Big Pirate was stalling my redemption and actively taking my deposits throughout October and November, I was in the middle of negotiating a settlement over a $4,100 deposit dispute with their sister site, Dorados. Neither site ever disclosed that they are operated by the exact same parent company, Rafflefy Limited.

For weeks, they insisted it was impossible to credit my bank account or card, aggressively pushing me to use Skrill even though I had never used it. Then, in early November, they turned around and refunded $2,500 back to a card—but it wasn't even the card I used on Dorados. It was actually 17 individual refunds for completely separate transactions I had made on Big Pirate. That unapproved, non-compliant refund structure is not only how they breached the waiver agreement, it's also the only reason I found out Big Pirate and Dorados are owned by the same company.

My experience with them boils down to stalling tactics on redemptions, zero transparency about who actually owns these platforms, and shady refund practices. Hopefully, this helps anyone looking into them before depositing. In my experience, the only way you will get their attention and have them take an issue seriously is by filing a formal arbitration claim
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Accredited Casinos

Back
Top