Logo
external image

Prediction markets: gambling, finance, or something in between?

Valge

I-Gaming Industry Representative Gofaizen & Sherle
Joined
Nov 12, 2025
Location
Rotterdam
The growth numbers are hard to ignore. Monthly volume went from under $100 million in early 2024 to over $13 billion by the end of 2025. Active users went from around 4,000 to over 600,000 in the same period. That kind of trajectory doesn't happen in a niche; it happens in a category that's finding mainstream traction.

How they actually work

The core mechanic is different from traditional betting. Users don't wager against a house; they trade probability contracts with each other. You buy a YES or NO position on an outcome, and you can exit that position before the event resolves. The platform takes a fee on matched trades and has no exposure to the result. It's structurally closer to a futures exchange than a sportsbook.

What people are betting on

Elections and political events are the obvious use case, but the markets have expanded well beyond that. Active contracts currently exist on AI product releases, entertainment awards, crypto price movements, geopolitical events, and considerably more niche outcomes. The range is partly what makes these platforms interesting from a market design perspective. Price discovery works on almost anything where there's genuine uncertainty and enough participants.

The main platforms

Kalshi is US-regulated and fought a legal battle to offer election contracts, which a federal appeals court cleared in 2024. Polymarket operates on-chain and has attracted significant volume in crypto-native audiences. PredictIt has been running under a CFTC no-action letter for years and remains one of the oldest active platforms. On the institutional side, DraftKings and FanDuel are developing prediction products, with FanDuel working alongside CME Group. Robinhood and Interactive Brokers are also reportedly exploring the space.

Why is this happening now

Regulatory clarity, particularly in the US, is the biggest unlock. Beyond that, the post-COVID retail trading wave brought a large new audience to probabilistic thinking about markets. There's also a structural shift in how younger demographics relate to financial products — peer-driven, transparent, and sceptical of traditional intermediaries.

Where it goes

Some projections put annual volume at $1 trillion by the end of the decade. Whether that materialises depends heavily on how regulators in other jurisdictions respond, and whether platforms can manage the reputational risk that comes with politically sensitive markets.

How are regulators in your region treating prediction markets, and do you think the current frameworks are equipped to handle something that sits this awkwardly between gambling and finance?
 
Interesting thread, and a lot has happened since April. I split my time between Romania and Brazil, and both have answered your question in the same direction.

Romania: ONJN blacklisted Polymarket in October 2025 after Romanians put over $600M on the presidential election. Their position was simple - it doesn't matter whether you bet in lei or crypto, if you stake money on a future result, it's gambling, and gambling here needs a state licence. ISPs were told to block it.

Brazil went further, but in a smarter way. About three weeks after your post, the National Monetary Council banned event contracts on sports, politics and elections, and 27 platforms including Polymarket and Kalshi were blocked. But contracts on economic indicators stayed legal under the securities regulator, so Kalshi's deal with XP on Brazilian macro data is still running.

So Brazil's answer to "gambling or finance?" is: it depends on what you're predicting, not on how the trade works. A YES contract on inflation is a derivative, the same contract on a football match is a bet. I think that's closer to the truth than either "it's all trading" or "it's all gambling".

The part I'm watching: blocking doesn't make the volume disappear, it just pushes it on-chain, where an ISP block does very little. Has anyone seen a regulator actually license these instead of blocking them? Liberia's $80k licence is the only example I know of so far.
 
Thanks for the update, and I agree with the Brazil logic.

To your question, Liberia isn’t the only one anymore. Gibraltar was first in Europe, with dedicated Prediction Market Regulations in July. And at the start of November, Nevis launched its own prediction market licence for operators and suppliers, at €18k a year. The UK and Malta are going another way, allowing these products under existing betting licences.

So it’s splitting three ways: block, license under existing betting rules, or create a dedicated licence. The obstacle is geo-blocking. Nevis requires blocking the US, UK and most big EU markets, which is where most of the volume is.
 
Thanks, that's a really useful map - I'd missed Gibraltar and Nevis.

The geo-blocking point is the interesting one. It's the same trade-off crypto casinos face with offshore licences: the licence itself is affordable, but the restricted list takes out the markets with the most money, so plenty of operators end up asking whether it's worth it at all.

Out of curiosity - do you see crypto casinos adding prediction markets under their existing Curaçao or Anjouan licences, or would that need a separate licence like Nevis? Feels like the obvious next product for them.
 
Interesting find. From what I've read, Belgium seems to draw the line at the licence rather than the product. The Kansspelcommissie blacklisted Polymarket back in January 2025 for operating without a Belgian licence, and Belgium is also one of the nine European regulators that teamed up against unlicensed prediction markets.

A licensed bookmaker adding prediction-style markets is a different story though - that would most likely sit under its existing betting licence, much like the UK and Malta model Valge mentioned.

Suppliers are already packaging this for bookmakers - BETBY launched a predictions product this spring and left out the more controversial markets - so I'd expect more licensed books to add a section like Starsport's. Doesn't fix the navigation though :)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Accredited Casinos

Back
Top