I vote Sci-Fi no rogue

[jetset]

Looking at this as a matter of scale the GP affair was considerably more prejudicial to many players, and the conduct of management worse.

I personally believe that judgements should be based on principle and fact although scale should be a factor, and if Sci Fi is "redeemed" then assuming GP applied they should be given the same consideration for consistency and fairness. That sticks in my craw after their behaviour in the past, but it should be done should they apply if we are to be consistent.

Their management had criminal convictions and did some pretty awful, dishonest and arrogant things back in 2000, which many people will find it hard to forgive. But it has to be said that there have been few complaints against them over the past year or more to my knowledge.

I personally think that Jyde has a point here - settle the old player issues (the one's you can still locate) before getting a clean bill of health.

[jpm]

I was just kidding jetset, I didn't actually mean GP should be redeemed. I still wouldn't go near them.