Bonus Complaint Winnings and deposits confiscated due to max bet breach at Royal Panda

IMO, that's the correct thing to do and that's what the OP did not do.
If he had done this, the chat support would have told him that he breached the terms of the bonus and that the bonus was therefore void.

So IMO it still comes down to the OP's not caring enough to be certain about the bonus terms of the bonus he was playing with.

Even at the best of casinos (such as Bet-at or Redbet where I accidentally exceed the max bet) the chat support does not pop in and point out to you that you have just exceeded max bet.
However, I did the same thing as you did (went immediately to chat, in my case sweating and panicking :)) and they said it's OK.

I was just using the bet example of how a good casino acts. He breached the max bet rule constantly so I think we are all in agreement he shouldnt get his winnings.

My opinion is about the deposit he made to clear wagering on a bonus he could never collect
 
Im with the casino on this one. To me it sounds straight forward.

Player was told the rules regarding his bonus in chat.

I believe there must've been some confusion, otherwise I don't see why the player would redeposit 350 USD. However the casino chat reps appear to have made a legitimate attempt to inform him.

The player lost his redeposits, so the question about giving back this is meaningless. He would've received it if he had won.
 
Player was told the rules regarding his bonus in chat.

I believe there must've been some confusion, otherwise I don't see why the player would redeposit 350 USD. However the casino chat reps appear to have made a legitimate attempt to inform him.

I was told on 26th of December about the rules. Melvin mentioned 16th of January as well, but I think I was not informed about that specific bonus in that day but the free spins conditions as I won on free spins and I wanted to cash out on that.

So on the day (22nd of Jan) I used the Friday Bamboo bonus I was not reminded (informed). This only matters, because I play in several casinos, so what was told a month (or at least a week) ago not necessarily remembered later especially if you consider my confusion of support chats with Videoslots (taken place on 14th of Jan and I have provided evidence about).

That goes for confiscating my winnings. But I am quite sure almost all accredited casino would have given back my deposits and some would even let me keep my winnings with a warning not to do it again after checking my play and my account history.
 
I was told on 26th of December about the rules. Melvin mentioned 16th of January as well, but I think I was not informed about that specific bonus in that day but the free spins conditions as I won on free spins and I wanted to cash out on that.

So on the day (22nd of Jan) I used the Friday Bamboo bonus I was not reminded (informed). This only matters, because I play in several casinos, so what was told a month (or at least a week) ago not necessarily remembered later especially if you consider my confusion of support chats with Videoslots (taken place on 14th of Jan and I have provided evidence about).

That goes for confiscating my winnings. But I am quite sure almost all accredited casino would have given back my deposits and some would even let me keep my winnings with a warning not to do it again after checking my play and my account history.

I am going to stick my nose in here and say that I think it is time, to just let it go............either avoid bonuses all together or be very sure you know the rules ahead of time. I too, bounce between a lot of different casinos. That's why I always go on chat before using a bonus to find out the rules. The majority of casinos in my US based experience, do NOT have a max bet rule while playing with bonus funds and trying to clear the wagering requirements. But some do, so I always ask ahead of time and then preserve a copy of the chat exchange in case there is ever an issues. Several times the saved "chat" has helped me. Usually if a chat person makes a mistakes and misinforms a player - the casino will honor the statement by the chat rep.

Diane
 
This is a tricky one for sure. I can see both sides in that I understand why a deposit could be confiscated (otherwise a player would have zero risk - if they lose, they could just make the last bet above the max and then say they broke the rules thus getting their deposit back) but also in this case, where the deposit appears to have been made to clear WR on winnings that were effectively already void, the software should prevent this IMO.

As someone else rightly said, it makes me wonder why anyone would want to take a bonus - it's got way too complicated. I don't generally have sympathy with players who claim bonuses and fall foul of the rules as the risks are well-known however in this case there is an argument that the deposit used to clear WR sounds like it could be refunded. Assuming we are party to all the facts of course and often we aren't.
 
Thats why most times I dont take a bonus unless its a good offer. Then I read the terms AND check with live support. I also take a screenshot of the terms.

I seriously feel like alot of casinos use these terms to screw as many players as possible. Why do you think the link to the terms is so small you can barely read it? Or sometimes you cant find it unless you really dig around?

All casinos should be like videoslots in this regard. You cant even violate the max bet rule cause the client will shut down on you if you even try.

Not meaning this casino just some in general.
 
I understand why a deposit could be confiscated (otherwise a player would have zero risk - if they lose, they could just make the last bet above the max and then say they broke the rules thus getting their deposit back)

I think it is easy to eliminate this risk.
Refund of deposit needs to be done only when there is winning (above the deposits) which would be void due to breach of bonus terms.
 
MGA answer

I just got an answer from the Malta Gaming Authority. I will copy it to the end of my post.

What they did basically is that they asked Royal Panda and accepted and repeated whatever they told. They did not address my following issues at all.

My problem is twofold:

First, they have ambigous bonus terms:

Please remember that the maximum bet permitted when playing with bonus money is $7.50, €7.00, £5.00, or its equivalent in another currency.

However, please keep in mind that there are games that offer different bet limits. You can find more information here:
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
. In the event of a breach of this rule, the player agrees that his bonus, and any associated winnings, may be void.

Which they apply as follows:

Your deposits, bonus and winnings will be void.

Second, they have confiscated not only my winnings, but my deposits as well. This is especially disturbing as a big part of the deposits (350 USD) were done after I had winnings on my account, but I needed deposits to fulfil the wagering requirement due to their special bonus setup (only cash bets contributes to the wagering, bonus bets not).

I have replied to MGA asking for their comments, but I won't hold my breath.

I have not played at Royal Panda since the incident (I guess Videoslots and Casumo was happy to get my business :p) and I will close my account when I get the final word from MGA (probably siding with the casino).

I hope at the end Royal Panda will find it was worth to alienate a loyal player (and probably others too) where a little goodwill would have gone a long way.

Sorry for the long post.

Here is the MGA answer:

Further to the below case, please be informed that we have received information from the representative of Royal Panda Limited (Royalpanda.com) who have informed the MGA that you have deposited on 15 January 2016, claiming a 50% bonus. You then contacted their customer service team via chat the following morning at 11:13AM, requesting information on how to meet the bonus wagering requirements. This was explained by one of their support (Please find below the chat from their support):-

· 11:24 Mateusz: The wagering requirement is only met using the cash balance. However unlike in other casinos the cash bonus wins are also added to cash even when you claim a deposit bonus. Which means that you can withdraw your cash when you score a big win while playing with it. To answer your question, if you play for bonus the wagering requirement will not be changed, unless you start playing for your cash.
· 11:24 Mateusz: Please remember that the maximum bet permitted when playing with bonus money is $7.50, €7.00, £5.00, or its equivalent in another currency.

Whilst their agent was explaining to you, you have proceeded to make another deposit via Skrill (which was processed at 11:23AM), you then resumed play at 11:25AM, which is to say AFTER you had been informed of the bet limits by their agent. They have also informed us that you have actually managed to release the bonus money you had amassed on 15 January. Specifically, you did so at 12:56PM on 16 January, using cash balance bets from the funds you deposited at 11:23AM. These were done using bets which were all within the limits, so there was no breach of Terms on this. You requested a withdrawal of the said funds shortly after this (at 12:58PM), which was duly checked by their payments team and as the bonus had been unlocked in the correct manner, this was paid out to your Skrill account at 12:23 on 17 January.

They have also informed us that on 22 January at 11:01 you claimed another bonus, receiving a further $50.00 bonus. You proceeded to place cash bets (i.e. from the $100.00 deposited) until 11:21, when the funds had been exhausted you than continued to play using your bonus balance. In this instance however the bets placed were largely in excess of the €7.50 limit, which their agent had explained to you on 16 January. You kept playing in this manner until 1:30 pm that day, by which point your bonus balance has risen to $1,261. You then made a further deposit of $100, at which point you returned to playing with your cash balance. You continued to place wagers using the said deposited funds until 2:31PM at which point these funds had been played. You then deposited a further $100 at 2.33PM, continuing to play with these funds until 2:42PM when you also played these funds. After playing with your bonus balance for a couple of minutes a further $100 deposit was made at 2:44PM. You then continued to make wagers until 2:48PM when with $9.80 left on your most recent deposit, you then deposited another $100.00 and you continued to play using this amount, eventually releasing your bonus to give you a combined withdrawable balance of $1,365.10 ($86.05 of your remaining deposited funds; $1,279.05 of released bonus funds) as 2:54PM. Then you continued to play. The wagers made were done so initially using your remaining deposited funds, until you had exhausted these funds at 2:59PM. You then continued to play using funds from your $1,279.05 released bonus.

On 22 January at 3:05PM and with $1,201.50 of unlocked bonus funds the only funds left on your account – you entered a withdrawal request for $1,200. This was rejected by the operator at 10:35AM the following morning and the funds confiscated on the grounds that your bonus bets violated their bonus betting limits.

With a summary of all this please note that you have been notified of the relevant limits when playing with bonus funds and how the wagering requirement for bonus funds can be met. You have successfully met the wagering requirements for the first bonus you received on 15 January and these were paid accordingly the following day after your withdrawal was requested. You have violated the terms limits by placing bonus bets in excess of the limits you had been informed of. Your deposited funds were not seized, because you have always played with deposited funds first before using the bonus balance (including released bonus funds), you had full use of the funds that were deposited on 22 January 2016. The only funds that were withhold were the remaining 1,201.50 of the remaining 1,279.05 bonus funds you had released in a manner that was not compliant with their Terms and Conditions after concluding your session on 22 January.

We wish to remind you that when you created your account you agreed to adhere to the Terms and Conditions and therefore the MGA cannot offer you further support with this specific case seeing that you had agreed to such Terms. We will have to consider the complaint case closed.
 
Some further comment.

This part is not true:

Royal Panda Limited (Royalpanda.com) who have informed the MGA that you have deposited on 15 January 2016, claiming a 50% bonus. You then contacted their customer service team via chat the following morning at 11:13AM, requesting information on how to meet the bonus wagering requirements. This was explained by one of their support (Please find below the chat from their support):-

· 11:24 Mateusz: The wagering requirement is only met using the cash balance. However unlike in other casinos the cash bonus wins are also added to cash even when you claim a deposit bonus. Which means that you can withdraw your cash when you score a big win while playing with it. To answer your question, if you play for bonus the wagering requirement will not be changed, unless you start playing for your cash.
· 11:24 Mateusz: Please remember that the maximum bet permitted when playing with bonus money is $7.50, €7.00, £5.00, or its equivalent in another currency.

Whilst their agent was explaining to you, you have proceeded to make another deposit via Skrill (which was processed at 11:23AM), you then resumed play at 11:25AM, which is to say AFTER you had been informed of the bet limits by their agent. They have also informed us that you have actually managed to release the bonus money you had amassed on 15 January. Specifically, you did so at 12:56PM on 16 January, using cash balance bets from the funds you deposited at 11:23AM. These were done using bets which were all within the limits, so there was no breach of Terms on this. You requested a withdrawal of the said funds shortly after this (at 12:58PM), which was duly checked by their payments team and as the bonus had been unlocked in the correct manner, this was paid out to your Skrill account at 12:23 on 17 January.


I did claim the 50% bonus on the 15th, but I lost it (deposit and bonus) then I had some free spins which I made big win with (see the picture below for the 2 bonuses on my account).

royal.JPG

So when I contacted the support for the terms I asked about the free spins win which was a completely different bonus (though the terms might have been the same).

That is so much about how accurate the information from Royal Panda and how detailed MGA investigation was (i.e. accepted everything what Royal Panda said).
 
Last edited:
First, they have ambigous bonus terms:

Please remember that the maximum bet permitted when playing with bonus money is $7.50, €7.00, £5.00, or its equivalent in another currency.

However, please keep in mind that there are games that offer different bet limits. You can find more information here:
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
. In the event of a breach of this rule, the player agrees that his bonus, and any associated winnings, may be void.

Which they apply as follows:

Your deposits, bonus and winnings will be void.

Second, they have confiscated not only my winnings, but my deposits as well. This is especially disturbing as a big part of the deposits (350 USD) were done after I had winnings on my account, but I needed deposits to fulfil the wagering requirement due to their special bonus setup (only cash bets contributes to the wagering, bonus bets not).

Hi Stokes,

I just want to clarify once again that your deposits were never void or confiscated, but you lost them instead. Your deposits were considered your own at all times, and both the deposit and any winnings would have been free to cash out at all times.

I am sorry for your bad experience and do understand your frustration, but the term of having a maximum bet permitted when playing with bonus money is not uncommon and you were informed about it on two separate occasions.

Once the bonus funds were confiscated, you contacted me before trying to resolve the issue with our support. Your conversation with them was still ongoing with them at the time. You initially gave me incorrect information that our support had misinformed you about our bonus terms, and instead of trying to work it out with me and or support in PM you decided to involve the casinomeister forum. Of course this is fine, but starts the entire discussion all over again. Before we can get to a collective agreement on the forum, you then decide to forward it to the MGA to make it a matter of who is right or wrong in the situation.

You talk about goodwill, but before even giving us a reasonable chance at that, you decide to seek support higher up. Should goodwill not come from both sides?

At this point, we will let the MGA decide the outcome of your case.

I also want to add that is never our intent to cheat players with our terms, and even on this forum you will find a lot of players who already have a good experience with Royal Panda.
 
Hi Stokes,

I just want to clarify once again that your deposits were never void or confiscated, but you lost them instead. Your deposits were considered your own at all times, and both the deposit and any winnings would have been free to cash out at all times.

I am sorry for your bad experience and do understand your frustration, but the term of having a maximum bet permitted when playing with bonus money is not uncommon and you were informed about it on two separate occasions.

Once the bonus funds were confiscated, you contacted me before trying to resolve the issue with our support. Your conversation with them was still ongoing with them at the time. You initially gave me incorrect information that our support had misinformed you about our bonus terms, and instead of trying to work it out with me and or support in PM you decided to involve the casinomeister forum. Of course this is fine, but starts the entire discussion all over again. Before we can get to a collective agreement on the forum, you then decide to forward it to the MGA to make it a matter of who is right or wrong in the situation.

You talk about goodwill, but before even giving us a reasonable chance at that, you decide to seek support higher up. Should goodwill not come from both sides?

At this point, we will let the MGA decide the outcome of your case.

I also want to add that is never our intent to cheat players with our terms, and even on this forum you will find a lot of players who already have a good experience with Royal Panda.

Hi Melvin,

When I contacted you, your support already told me (in a fancy way) to sod off. I misinformed you, because I mixed you up your casino with other casino (I think I showed enough evidence about it).
I contacted MGA, because you told me in numerous occasions to sod off (again in a fancy way).

You (Royal Panda Casino) misinformed me and MGA saying that I was informed about the bonus terms of your Bamboo bonus a week earlier (16th of Jan). I proved that it was not true. I was informed about the terms of free spins by that time as I was quite surprised that I need to do deposit to release a winnings from free spins.

You keep repeating that my deposits were not confiscated, but simply forget to answer why would I do deposits (350 USD) if I knew my bonus would be void?

The goodwill should have been employed when the one (who thought my winnings and deposits should be confiscated) checked my account and saw that I had not employ the classic bonus abuse tactic and I had been a member for about a year with more than 20 deposits.

I also mentioned that it happened to me at other casino (who started to use max bet within their terms and I did not check), but they at least gave back my deposit. You did not. Not even the initial deposit (I know you say that I lost it, but it was the same with the other casino, the bets are deducted from the cash balance first.).

I did not say that you wanted to cheat players. You just simply wants to keep as much money as you can employing the bonus rules strictly. After all the confiscated money is an extra profit which comes above what you get in a normal operation (the normal profit).
Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of casinos doing the same thing like yours (confiscating as much money as they can). I just want to play at the handful other outfits who does it differently.

Yesterday I have asked your support to close my account at Royal Panda (I know, I should have waited for the goodwill to come:rolleyes:).
 
Hi Stokes,

I misinformed you, because I mixed you up your casino with other casino (I think I showed enough evidence about it).
While I believe you made an honest mistake at the time, as a casino we get many false claims and statements by players trying to get back their losses. Not saying this was your intent or not, but at the time our information was that you were warned twice + lied to me about being misinformed by our support. Instead of trying to explain and resolve the situation, you then posted your story on the forum.

You keep repeating that my deposits were not confiscated, but simply forget to answer why would I do deposits (350 USD) if I knew my bonus would be void?
We have plenty of players depositing without any bonus. Your deposit in this case could be regarded as just so. While I understand your point of view and reason for depositing, it is not as simple as just being able to refund you in this situation, since this would mean that we would have to confiscate player winnings in these situations which is something we definitely do not want to do. (It would mean that any play while breached terms and conditions has to be voided, while other players might be perfectly happy to continue playing with their own funds.).

I did not say that you wanted to cheat players. You just simply wants to keep as much money as you can employing the bonus rules strictly. After all the confiscated money is an extra profit which comes above what you get in a normal operation (the normal profit).
Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of casinos doing the same thing like yours (confiscating as much money as they can). I just want to play at the handful other outfits who does it differently.
This is not at all our intention, and I'm sorry you feel this way.

You (Royal Panda Casino) misinformed me and MGA saying that I was informed about the bonus terms of your Bamboo bonus a week earlier (16th of Jan). I proved that it was not true. I was informed about the terms of free spins by that time as I was quite surprised that I need to do deposit to release a winnings from free spins.
This explanation was about any bonus money, which is all considered the same at Royal Panda. It does not matter if your Bonus Balance comes from a reward, deposit bonus or free spins.

Yesterday I have asked your support to close my account at Royal Panda (I know, I should have waited for the goodwill to come)
Of course I understand your decision, and I'm sorry that you had a bad experience with us.
 
Hi Stokes,

While I believe you made an honest mistake at the time, as a casino we get many false claims and statements by players trying to get back their losses. Not saying this was your intent or not, but at the time our information was that you were warned twice + lied to me about being misinformed by our support. Instead of trying to explain and resolve the situation, you then posted your story on the forum.

I have sent 4 private messages before started the thread. In your second reply you mentioned that I was wrong (lied as you put it now) as I did not get false information from the support. I accepted it (in my reply saying that I might have mixed up your casino with Videoslots). In your last PM you suggested to keep working with your support and contact you if I feel that I am right. I replied to that I opened the thread, because the casino support rejected to reinstate my winnings or refund my deposits and I thought that is the official answer from the casino.

We have plenty of players depositing without any bonus. Your deposit in this case could be regarded as just so.

Do you also have plenty of players who has 1400 USD credit on their account AND redeposit?


This explanation was about any bonus money, which is all considered the same at Royal Panda. It does not matter if your Bonus Balance comes from a reward, deposit bonus or free spins.

Different casinos have different terms for the free spins. For example many of them do not attach wagering for free spins winnings.

Of course I understand your decision, and I'm sorry that you had a bad experience with us.

What made me very upset is that the casino treated me like a bonus abuser without checking the history of my account. I did not use any bonus abusing method, just raised my bets when I felt lucky.

As mentioned earlier, I don't get this whole max bet restriction stuff. What casinos wants to avoid? Some lucky bonus abusers (most of them will lose out due to the wagering and the RTP)? How can those casinos survive who do not have max bet rule?
 
I have sent 4 private messages before started the thread. In your second reply you mentioned that I was wrong (lied as you put it now) as I did not get false information from the support. I accepted it (in my reply saying that I might have mixed up your casino with Videoslots). In your last PM you suggested to keep working with your support and contact you if I feel that I am right. I replied to that I opened the thread, because the casino support rejected to reinstate my winnings or refund my deposits and I thought that is the official answer from the casino.

My appologies, maybe lied is not the right wording, misinformed would be a nicer way of putting it. Though from our internal perspective at the time we do not have that information.
I had 1 message with the initial request from you, on that one I replied with
Hi Zoltan,

I will definitely look into this for you, however since it's weekend I'm not sure if I will have an answer for you before Monday.

If our support has indeed given you incorrect information about the maximum bet with bonus money, I completely agree with you and will make sure that you will get all your bonus winnings back.

Let me know if there is anything else I can do for you.

Regards,
Melvin

On monday morning, I followed up with:

Hi Zoltan,

Unfortunately I can't find any proof of your claim that our customer support have misinformed you about the wagering restrictions with bonus money. All I can find, is that Mateusz correctly informed you about the restrictions on 16 January, I copied the transcript below:

"16 January 2016 11:13
11:24 Mateusz : Please remember that the maximum bet permitted when playing with bonus money is $7.50, €7.00, £5.00, or its equivalent in another currency.

However, please keep in mind that there are games that offer different bet limits. You can find more information here:
You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.
. In the event of a breach of this rule, the player agrees that his bonus, and any associated winnings, may be void.

11:24 Zoltan Simon: I see. Thanks"

Since you were clearly correctly informed, confirmed it via chat, and made a false claim, I am afraid that it is not possible to give you back the bonus money in this case.

Do let me know if there is anything else I can do for you.

You then informed me about the videoslots confusion + requested a refund, but I got informed by our support that they are still in conversation with you as well. so I replied the following on Monday evening:

Hi Zoltan,

When contacting our customer service, they told me that you are still in contact with them as well.

It makes sense to try to solve the situation with them first, and only if you really can't get to an agreement with them but you believe that you are right, you can contact me again with all the information. I can't spend my time on customer queries all day, but in case anyone is treated unfairly I do ofcourse want to help out.

I hope you understand this, and I also hope that you can resolve your issue with the customer service.

Regards,
Melvin

The next message I got from you informed me about this thread that you had opened, while I suggested that if you could not get to an agreement with our support you should contact me again and I would see what I can do.

Both of my replies were done on the first day after the weekend (25 January), and I showed intent to help you from the start. Even confirming your initial request on a Saturday and before checking with anyone I promised you that if your claim was correct, you would get your entire bonus to cash out.
 
I understand the players frustration, and i really do feel for you as im sure you did not do this to abuse but rather recreational strategy for minimizing losses (win as much as we can so the losses dont get to big as we always loose in the end).
However it is not hard to understand the casino and their decission. If you had won say 1200 with the real money you would have been able to keep them.
If they enforced deposit back for winners and looser you would then loose the 1200 which would be much worse as it was with real money.

If they just give back to loosers, well that is very open to abuse.

As for the max bet, if you bet 20E a spin the chances of hitting something good is reduced yes, but it you hit you will be able to WD.
IF you bet 5E you will have much higher odds of hitting a big win, but still not necesarily withdrawing.

Edit:
A clarification, this thread hos not made it less likely to try out the casino. However, if they had refunded the player i would have definately tried it.
Cant expect them to, but if they did it would show compassion for their customers.
 
The next message I got from you informed me about this thread that you had opened, while I suggested that if you could not get to an agreement with our support you should contact me again and I would see what I can do.

Both of my replies were done on the first day after the weekend (25 January), and I showed intent to help you from the start. Even confirming your initial request on a Saturday and before checking with anyone I promised you that if your claim was correct, you would get your entire bonus to cash out.

I guess that was a misunderstanding from my part. I thought that you want me to contact you if I found evidence that I was misinformed by the online support. I also thought that you discussed the issue with the support guys and their answer was the official answer so no meaning to contact you again.

Anyhow, you could have contacted me right after my first post to discuss any friendly solution. But, to be honest I was (and still am) very upset with your process which conveniently confiscates any deposits together with the winnings, so I wanted to seek fellow members opinion.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Meister Ratings

Back
Top