The Prepaid Debit Card Takes Advantage of the Disadvantaged

jas2587

Dormant account
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Location
FL
October 9, 2009. By Gordon Gibb

Washington, DC: As if the credit card companies and banks aren't making enough already, now consumers who can least afford to pay credit card user fees are being put into an even tighter financial noose while the proprietors of prepaid debit cards, such as Green Dot Visa, are raking in the cash that to some is yet another example of credit card consumer abuse.

A joint investigation by the New York Times and the PBS program 'Frontline' has exposed the murky user fees behind an industry that is about to mushroom.

Prepaid, pre-loaded debit cards have grown as a natural extension of entities such as prepaid phone cardsand are directed at the 'unbanked' consumer. That is to say, consumers who do not have a regular association with a bank, or don't have a bank at all.

They can't qualify for a standard credit card. They may have lousy credit. And there are an estimated 80 million of them out there.

And so along comes the pre-paid debit card that promises no credit check, or no requirement for a bank account. Just buy it and fly it.

However, as the New York Times / Frontline investigation reveals, the cards come with a basket of user fees that are often hidden in the fine print.

Take the MiCash Prepaid MasterCard, for example. According to an expose appearing this week in the New York Times the new debit cardholder is docked an immediate $9.95 activation fee. And that's just the beginning: use it at the ATM and it costs you $1.75 for each withdrawal. A simple ATM balance inquiry will cost you a buck. There's a 50-cent fee for each purchase, $4 in monthly maintenance, a $2 fee for not using it within 60 days and a buck-a-call to contact customer service.

And that's just one prepaid debit card. Others charge similar fees.

Spokespersons for the prepaid debit card industry maintain that for those without banking privileges, prepaid is less expensive than the fees charged at check-cashing boutiques.

Critics say the cards take advantage of a segment of the population already at a disadvantage.

The Times article tells of one young fellow who turned to a Pay-O-Matic card after a bank turned him down for an account because he lacked one, of two required pieces of ID. His alternative was to park the proceeds of his paycheck onto the prepaid debit card.
It wasn't long before he began to notice the accumulation of fees. It was only when he returned to the Pay-O-Matic store to complain that he was given a detailed list of two-dozen fees.

Beneficiaries such as Visa, MasterCard and Discover earn anywhere from a nickel, to 20 cents each time a prepaid debit card is swiped.

And for what? That's what consumer advocates are asking.


Prepaid Debit Card Legal Help
If you have suffered losses in this case, please send your complaint to a lawyer who will review your possible [Prepaid Debit Card Lawsuit] at no cost or obligation

Just a heads up will they all go this way???

You do not have permission to view link Log in or register now.



Cindy:)
 
As with everything else, one needs to shop around to find the best deal on everything these days and freedom is never free so those of us that feel we have a right to spend our money the way we like have to pay a little more I imagine but to me it is worth it. And if I add bank fees and prepaid fees up at the end of the year, I just bet my bank would win. Either way, we lose. ;) thanks for sharing that jas2587
 
Hiya: BoA charges all those same fee's. Plus, if you goof, they will LET you be overdrawn, just to add the $30 fee for that. Most people who do not have a bank acct, do not have a pre paid debit card either. They cash their check at a Casino, or check cashing place, and hide the Cash in their apartment.

If you ever wondered why Poor peoples apartments get broken into more often than others, this is the main reason. Is there anything left anymore that does not charge a fee? I asked on the internet, but had to pay a $1.50 info request fee, so i am asking here instead......hehehehe:D
 
[


They can't qualify for a standard credit card. They may have lousy credit. And there are an estimated 80 million of them out there.

Critics say the cards take advantage of a segment of the population already at a disadvantage.

I don't disagree with your argument here BUT what is the alternative?
Me , for example use a debit card because no freaking US credit card will allow me to deposit to an online casino
I go to a check cashing store toreload my card and what I see there is criminal
The "underpriveleged "pays light bill, phone bill , gas bill and all those other bills here and there is a fee for each bill..What's absurd is the fact that they pay a humongous fee to cash their paycheck in order to pay these bills

Regarding the ATM withdrawal with a debit card , the big sophisticated banks also rips you off when you withdraw from a bank that is not theirs...This crap goes on and on and it sickens me..Yet we vote these guys into congress and they do nothing to help the poor folks..They only look out for themselves ala Charlie Rangel. Well only in America and Afghanistan and other baana republics :-( Still I would not want to live anywhere else
 
I have two prepaid cards, Netspend and Wired Plastic. Have had these since they came out, I guess, and love them. Neither of these cards charge any more than the bank accounts I have had. I can get a bank account, just don't want one. I pay a small fee each month, just like a bank charges and that's it. I pay my bills online and have used these cards all over the US. Besides, knock on wood, they will still let me use my own money whereever I want to. ;)

People go to check cashing places because banks won't cash checks anymore. Prime example, I was issued a check from an insurance company for a car accident. Couple of thousand and written on Chase Bank. Went to the local Chase bank to cash it. Guess what, wouldn't cash it because I didn't have a bank account there. Well duh, I didn't write the check, one of their customers did. If banks will no longer cash checks written by their customers then who is left that will cash them? Check cashing business and, in Texas, the local liquor store. :D They can charge the amount allowed by the gov. and provide a service that banks won't. Do I like it? Do I think people are getting ripped off by them? No and yes.

I vote. Most of the time with the feeling that it won't make any difference anyway but I exercise my right as a US citizen. Maybe one day I will make a difference.
 
I have used pre paid cards to fund my online gaming for years. It cost me 2 bucks to load my card and 7 bucks a month for some other fee but that is it. There probably is some few for using it at an ATM but I never have done that. I have 3 bank accounts and 4 credit cards both in U.S and Canadian but I choose to go this route for 2 reasons, 1. I can only spend what I load on the card and 2. if some one were to get my numbers from the card there probably wouldn't be any money on it. So for a few bucks a month I don't mind.
 
2 bucks to load on mine (Titanium) and 7 bucks a month if there is money on the card. If there is no money on the card the 7 dollar fee is scratched and does not carry to the next month.

I rarely pay the 7 dollar fee because I only load what I plan to use right away. The odd time I've dragged my heels and they scooped the 7 bucks but that's my own fault.

The real benefit of a pre-paid card is there is no credit. I can use it anywhere online or on land and never fear anyone will get my credit card number. If I use it online to make a purchase and some seedy website steals my Visa number, more power to you. You'll have to load it to get any money from it anyway. And good luck with that since I'm the only person who's allowed to load it. :p

It's also great for teens who need the benefit of a credit card to make purchases online but might not be trusted with real credit or can't pay a monthly bill.

In short, it's not very expensive and it's 100% safe to use.
 
I opted with Titanium to pay a monthly fee of $15, and I am charged nothing for loading it, or making any payments. This is instead of the $7.95 (I believe) fee, plus $2 loads and .50 per transaction. Since I load at least once a week, I'm happy with that.

I do have a bank account, can even load my card from it as a "Bill payment", but that takes two business days to show up. Prevents late night "one more try" deposits, and helps keep me in my gambling budget. I've never withdrawn from an ATM with it, but I have used it at restaurants, beer store and for online purchases. Hotels have accepted it to make reservations, but I have to leave a cash deposit upon check-in because it is not really a credit card. Although I didn't end up using it for that purpose, a number of calls to car rental places found one that would accept it if I had a balance high enough ($500) for a pre-authorization to rent a vehicle.

And since it is NOT a credit card, no high interest charges!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Meister Ratings

Back
Top