I recently won over 2500 here, and I really thought I had been ripped off and they weren't going to pay me. It turns out the problem was my own fault. Thier email address has a number of dashes in it, and I ended up emailing the wrong email address several times.
Also, one of thier CSR's accused me of fraud, in the online chat. (But didn't explain to me the bj requirement was 15x)
This was resolved once I finally did get the right email and contacted management. Since then, I was paid in full (and very quickly). I now have made a number of other deposits and withdrawals, and have always been paid very quickly. I immediately posted a retraction to my negative comments on Winneronline.
Despite my personal situation, I do believe Sci-Fi had many problems in the past, especially the Ted M situation. I've always personally felt that Ted M got screwed by Sci-Fi. There is no excuse for a casino not keeping proper accounting records. Granted that the player admits not keeping the complete records either (as per Julie at Gambling Grumbles). But, the burden of proper record keeping should always be on the casino. Kudos to Julie for working so hard for a settlement.
I also have read many of the player disputes from later 2001 and WOL, and am not convinced that Sci-Fi did the right thing. I think certain players were not treated fairly. They retroactively took back previously granted bonuses, when a player was accused of violating terms. This, in itself, rings alarm bells with me. I think there is no worse crime a casino could commit. Also, at that time, craps play was allowed, but thier terms didn't explain which plays were excluded. This is the casino's fault. Most of those players have not been paid. Was this just used as an excuse to screw players out of thier winnings?
So -- I have very mixed feelings here. I am glad that I haven't read any major complaints about Sci-Fi in the last 6-8 months. Management seems to really have improved the way it does business, and the way it treats customers. They payout very quickly (24-48 hours), and live chat is extremely helpful. Also they have $1 bj and Pontoon. Bonuses are above average.
On the other hand, I do not believe thier past crimes can be forgiven (just as in the GP situation), and I know 3 players that claim they have not been paid from thier disputes of late 2001.
~B, Although I agree with your decision to remove Sci-Fi from your rogue listing, I am unsure if I agree with your decision to redeem them completely, just yet. I am a little surprised you didn't wait MORE TIME before granting them a redemption.