1. By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies .This website or its third-party tools use cookies, which are necessary to its functioning and required to achieve the purposes illustrated in the cookie policy.Find out more.
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Dismiss Notice
  3. Follow Casinomeister on Twitter | Facebook | YouTube | Casinomeister.us US Residents Click here! |  Svenska Svenska | 
Dismiss Notice
REGISTER NOW!! Why? Because you can't do diddly squat without having been registered!

At the moment you have limited access to view most discussions: you can't make contact with thousands of fellow players, affiliates, casino reps, and all sorts of other riff-raff.

Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join Casinomeister here!

Casinos: Offer the option of half-back on the house edge instead of bonuses?

Discussion in 'Online Casinos' started by zreb, Oct 10, 2018.

    Oct 10, 2018
  1. zreb

    zreb Experienced Member

    Location:
    currently in US
    As pretty much everyone here knows, most online casinos offer a slew of percentage based deposit bonuses as promotions for their players. +150% on initial deposits, weekly addons, new game specials, so on and on, you get some extra money to play with in exchange for depositing at the casino.

    But over the years, those bonuses have come with more and more strings attached, more restrictions, and higher wagering requirements. Many choose to avoid these bonuses altogether rather than dealing with large wagering requirements and reading through pages of terms and conditions. While most casinos do offer "comp point" systems, they are usually nearly worthless and are applied to both bonus and non-bonus play anyway.

    So, I was wondering if casinos are able or willing to offer an alternative - returning players a fraction (half?) of the expected house edge for what they wager on a given game (whether in $ or in equivalent comp points).

    This has some advantages - for one, unlike bonuses, it's usually impossible for a casino to be "beaten" with such a system. That means they don't have to worry about advantage players or anyone else having an edge against them.

    In turn, this means they could offer this to players without any sort of restrictions, wagering requirements, prohibited games, maximum bets and so on. I would think such a system would appeal to those who deposit without bonuses anyway to avoid the hassle.

    Additionally, as a player, there are times when I might have completed a wagering requirement and want to keep playing, but feel like I would probably be better off redepositing somewhere else with a bonus for better odds. With a discount or cash back on the house edge, you could keep playing however long you felt like and it would still be there for you.

    I know some "brick and mortar" casinos offer a system with a similar idea already in "non-negotiable chips" - a roundabout system which basically allows players to be paid for every bet they make. It should be way, way easier for online casinos to implement when every bet a player makes is logged electronically.

    This wouldn't necessarily have to be in place of bonuses, a casino could offer players a choice if they desired. Personally I actually don't mind bonus systems, though there are times I'd rather just have a discount on the house edge and know that I can play whatever game I want without restrictions or worrying about withdrawing/redepositing to keep playing with a bonus.

    So my questions would be: If I requested something like this instead of taking a bonus, is this something many online casinos would be willing or able to offer right now? Do they have the technical capability of doing it without having to do it individually/manually calculate the house take for every game played? (If it were manual, I'd guess they would only do it for very high rollers)

    And even if casinos wouldn't do it now, is it something they would offer in the future?

    I think this system would make a lot of players happy, but if anyone feels they can agree or disagree with that statement.
     
  2. Oct 10, 2018
  3. Harry_BKK

    Harry_BKK Senior Member CAG mm1

    Occupation:
    job is OK
    Location:
    Balcony
    Check out Videoslots, that is exactly what they are doing. 25% of the house edge after deduction overheads, taxes etc. paid once a week on Fridays as cashback.
     
  4. Oct 11, 2018
  5. Reelsoffun

    Reelsoffun Full Member

    Location:
    UK
    And if your playing regularly you will also get reel race money every week on a Monday too, so deffo check out Videoslots as i would highly recommend them too as they do exactly what you seem to be after.
     
    Mouche12 likes this.
  6. Oct 12, 2018
  7. Playford7

    Playford7 Senior Member

    Occupation:
    Offshore worker
    Location:
    North east England
    Harry are you on VS payroll lol
     
    Harry_BKK likes this.
  8. Oct 12, 2018
  9. Harry_BKK

    Harry_BKK Senior Member CAG mm1

    Occupation:
    job is OK
    Location:
    Balcony
    Absolutely not. In contrary, VS is on my payroll, they're getting 10's of thousands every year for allowing me to spin some strange reels which is rarely profitable. :D
     
    adamtheaddict, deaconk78 and Mouche12 like this.
  10. Oct 12, 2018
  11. brianmon

    brianmon Meister Member webby mm4

    Location:
    uk
    Isn't the OP in the states? Doubt he'll have much luck joining VS
     
  12. Oct 12, 2018
  13. Harry_BKK

    Harry_BKK Senior Member CAG mm1

    Occupation:
    job is OK
    Location:
    Balcony
    Didn't see that when he originally posted. IIRC, it said UK.
     
    Last edited: Oct 12, 2018
  14. Oct 12, 2018
  15. Playford7

    Playford7 Senior Member

    Occupation:
    Offshore worker
    Location:
    North east England
    I was only joking Harry, no offence intended
     
    Harry_BKK likes this.
  16. Oct 12, 2018
  17. Harry_BKK

    Harry_BKK Senior Member CAG mm1

    Occupation:
    job is OK
    Location:
    Balcony
    None taken

    I understood it as a joke, hence, the laughing face at the end of my answer. :D
     
    Playford7 likes this.
  18. Oct 12, 2018
  19. L&L-Jan

    L&L-Jan Affiliate Manager for Accredited Casinos

    Occupation:
    Affiliate Manager
    Location:
    Malta
    You can request that with me and I'll say: No Bonus Casino.

    Kr. Jan
     
    Harry_BKK likes this.
  20. Oct 12, 2018
  21. Harry_BKK

    Harry_BKK Senior Member CAG mm1

    Occupation:
    job is OK
    Location:
    Balcony
    Of course Jan. I should have mentioned that in my answer. Sorry, but sometimes we wear our VS glasses too tight. :oops:

    Good game choice you have meanwhile, what a change from the Amatic/MG/Netent only days. Just today, I upgraded the ratings for all your brands to reflect that.
     
    L&L-Jan likes this.
  22. Oct 12, 2018
  23. L&L-Jan

    L&L-Jan Affiliate Manager for Accredited Casinos

    Occupation:
    Affiliate Manager
    Location:
    Malta
    You are a true star :)

    IGT is coming and Novomatic. From there we take a break in regards to integrations and focus on gamification. Oh, its going to be a great 2019 :)

    Kr.
     
    Jono777 and Harry_BKK like this.
  24. Oct 12, 2018
  25. ESCJAMIE

    ESCJAMIE Full Member

    Location:
    Dudley
    I love this idea more casinos should do it
     
    zreb likes this.
  26. Oct 12, 2018
  27. zreb

    zreb Experienced Member

    Location:
    currently in US
    Yeah I am in the U.S. now, but I was also curious if casinos were willing to do this in general, so interesting to know. Was hoping it would be a bit higher than 12.5% (50% of 25% if I'm reading it right?) with a few restrictions (progressives and max per day), but accompanied with the other promotion it sounds like a pretty good choice for people.

    I would think casinos could afford to give players a 50% discount on the house edge for slot games, but I can't be completely sure without knowing licencing/processing/other costs. A 50% discount doesn't even mean the casino makes 50% less because players will be able to play longer anyway, both because they don't run out of money as fast and they may be more inclined to play longer knowing the games aren't just raking them over the coals to take as much money as possible.

    And of course, the goal of the system is that you get far more players in the first place since not many are offering it and it should appeal to a large niche of people who know that deposit bonuses are not the free money they are advertised to be. Unless I'm overestimating the number of gamblers that actually care whether they have a reasonable chance of winning, which I guess I could be, maybe 99% of people just see a big number next to a deposit bonus, pick a shiny slot machine, and sit down.

    My suggestion seems so obvious to me that I'm almost surprised more casinos aren't offering it. Most incentive schemes offered to players have to compromise between making it appealing to players without getting hammered by the savvier ones. This system doesn't have to worry about that, the only way the casino can lose is if the games or RNG have exploitable bugs. How could a casino not hear that and perk their ears up?

    And in turn, the players themselves simply get a better deal on the games. Nothing crazy or flashy, just better odds of winning, confidence that the casino gives them a decent chance of winning without trying to pillage every cent in front of them every single time they play. Well, if I ran a casino, I'm pretty sure I would try to set up something like that. It just seems too obvious not to do.

    Are you saying you would give players cash back on the house edge? Because 10% cashback on losses is really not quite the same... 10% is kind of pitiful for slot play, but if you try to offer higher amounts (25%+) you have the same issues with deposit bonuses where you have to start attaching a bunch of terms and conditions.

    If you run a solid and reliable casino that's great, but the point is to offer players a system that competes with deposit bonuses in value without the excessive restrictions and issues they have, not to simply take away the bonuses.
     
  28. Oct 12, 2018
  29. Reelsoffun

    Reelsoffun Full Member

    Location:
    UK


    12.5% Are you insane? ;) your never going to be getting that when the average slot house edge is less than 4%

    I might be wrong but i have understood the weekend booster to be calculated as about 0.5% back on a typical 96% RTP game which dont sound much but it adds up over the week if your playing anyway.

    Generally casinos would only ever want to give back 1% max on slot play or often 0.1% back on table games as such anyway so its not as tight as it sounds.


    By the sound of it your expecting unrealistic bonuses / loyalty perks, and are focusing more on the total amount you lose rather than the theoretical loss you would get.


    As an example if i was to bet one spin of £100 of a slot i have lost £100 if the casino even gave me £10 cashback they would technically be at a loss as although i lost 100 over long term i would / should only have lost £4 therefore you can see the issue if they were to consistently give back bonuses of 10% cashback on losses.

    This is the same reason that 100% bonues and the like have so much wagering its to neutralize the +EV created by the bonus.

    For me Videoslots have it spot on, it gives you some cashback every week which extends playtime eg FUN ! ( which is what this should be all about, having FUN ), and its a very fair bonus that the more you play the more you get, whether you won or lost that week. For me its the reason I have closed over a dozen casinos since joining them. To me it is one of the best loyalty reward programs I have come across and the countless casinos I have played at, well done VS.


    For now no other casinos have cottoned on to how much players like this no nonsense approach to bonuses or loyalty so I would expect VS to go from strength to strength while we hear of others closing down week after week.

    Its a shame that you can't play there.

    Just my opinions on it all anyway.
     
    Last edited: Oct 12, 2018
  30. Oct 12, 2018
  31. zreb

    zreb Experienced Member

    Location:
    currently in US
    12.5% of the house edge, not 12.5% of the amount wagered. On a 4% house edge game, that would be a .5% return on your money wagered (4%*.125 = .5%), as you said.

    Returning half of the house edge would be 2%, but that's assuming no other substantial promotions. The 2% remaining house edge is still a reasonably high house edge considering the overhead should be way less than a live casino, and spins can happen fairly quickly, and as I said before, lower house edge = longer playing sessions anyway, even if not quite double.

    But I don't know if there are software licensing costs, bizarre tax rules, or other problems that would make a 50% edge reduction infeasible.

    Yes you could technically beat a 10% cashback bonus with a single max bet. Which is kind of my point. Anything more generous than this and you get more and more restrictive wagering conditions.

    So the option is either the "normal" players get a measly 10% cashback on slot losses to make sure the rare mr. $100 single spin won't make much money off the casino. Or you add a bunch of bonus restrictions to prevent mr. $100 single spin from being able to do that and add wagering requirements, but give a more generous bonus (25%+).

    The entire point of what I said is you can avoid that situation, just paying people back a fraction of the expected house take. If mr. $100 spin comes along, he just gets $2 back. Someone who loses with smaller wagers over a long period maybe gets $10-$50 back. (Technically, in some instances it could actually be higher than $100 back.)

    I don't think this system will completely replace regular bonuses because there is high demand for those, but it should be a good option.

    You realize I'm 90% agreeing with you, right? I think it's a pretty good system, but they have very few competitors doing the same thing. I wish it were a bit higher than 12.5%, but they have another wagering race promotion instead.
     
    Last edited: Oct 12, 2018
  32. Oct 12, 2018
  33. SlotGrinder

    SlotGrinder Senior Member

    Occupation:
    Poker Player
    Location:
    England
    Trada allow you to use a code CB25 and get cashback of 25% of your deposit amount . Every £70 you wager you get £2 cash . Thats nice and simple
    Fro 1st deposit I think you get 100% of your deposit amount
    I think the average punter is more enticed by "Free £10 !" or "deposit £50 and play with £100!"
    than by gettiing some % of losses back tho
     
    zreb likes this.
  34. Oct 12, 2018
  35. zreb

    zreb Experienced Member

    Location:
    currently in US
    Interesting, that sounds even more generous than what I suggested (~2.85% paid per slot wager), though of course the trade off is that it runs out.

    You're right that more people probably prefer the straight up bonus, but if even 5-20% of players really don't want to deal with bonuses, that's a huge potential "niche" of the casino market to serve.

    To clarify in case anyone doesn't understand, I'm not talking about cash back on losses, I'm talking about being paid a % back of the expected house take for every bet made.

    Look up "non-negotiable chips", that's a more convoluted way of doing what I'm suggesting used in live casinos, I believe primarily in Asian casinos. The chips are just used to track how many bets people made to pay them back on the house edge. With online games, you don't need the convoluted tracking method, you have all the info available easily and can pay back a % of money for every bet made directly (or with comp points that can be instantly converted to dollars if you want people to see how much they "earned.") The % of money paid back I suggest should be based on rtp of course, you're not going to pay back 2% on craps or video poker.

    It's hard to believe that if live casinos can do this that online casinos can't afford to repay more than 25% of house edge back.
     
    Last edited: Oct 12, 2018
  36. Oct 12, 2018
  37. Playford7

    Playford7 Senior Member

    Occupation:
    Offshore worker
    Location:
    North east England
    Great casino, it’s only the lack of providers that stops me playing here.
     

Share This Page